Breaking News
Home / Clarifications / Explaining the Saying “Fulan has agreed with Ahlul Bidah in such and such”Shaykh Ahmed An-Najjar
Ahlul bidah arabic

Explaining the Saying “Fulan has agreed with Ahlul Bidah in such and such”Shaykh Ahmed An-Najjar

Fulan has agreed with Ahlul Bidah in such and such”

 

It is the kind of agreement that is restricted and specific not Absolute and general
Its place is not to be exceeded
Like the saying Fulan from Ahlul sunnah is in agreement with the Jahmiyyah or the Mutazilah or any of the sects from Ahlul-Bidah
It doesn’t mean that he is agreement with those sects in their usool (fundamental principles) and that he takes the same ruling as them.
This expression is only used to warn from his statement and that nobody deems it permissible to use his statement.
This has been explained by Shaykhul Islam in Majmoor Fatwa volume 12 page 206
And he has become from the Jahmiyyah in some issues

Meaning he has agreed with the Jahmiyyah in it
So as to make clear the weakness of his statement and not that his ruling is like their ruling, this would not be said by the one who knows what he is saying”
Written By Ahmed An-Najjar
Translated by Jafar ibn Ruel Jeffrey

http://abuasmaa12.blogspot.co.uk/2016/02/blog-post_13.html?spref=tw&m=1

About Salafibayaan

Check Also

notice-from-the-amir-of-jizan

The Amir of Jizan Saudi Arabia takes an agreement from Fawaz al-Madkhali and and Yahya al-Jabiri to not discuss issues pertaining to the Honour of the Scholars or Du’aat

  Full translation to follow shortly