Breaking News
Home / Refutations / A refutation on shaykh Ahmed Bazmool’s Book “siyantus salafi” (Arabic only) الإبانة عن خيانة(الصيانة)-لأحمد بازمول- للعدل والأمانة
REFUTED IMAGE

A refutation on shaykh Ahmed Bazmool’s Book “siyantus salafi” (Arabic only) الإبانة عن خيانة(الصيانة)-لأحمد بازمول- للعدل والأمانة

 

Click here to Download pdf AL-EBANA

 

Shaykh ’AbdulMalik ar-Ramadānī al-Jazā’irī (hafidhahullāh) stated: “This book [by Ahmad Bāzmūl] has been censured by Shaykh [’AbdulMuhsin] al-’Abbād!”

See: http://salafimanhaj.com/pdf/SalafiManhaj_JazairiOnStudents

The book was refuted in detail by Abu’l-’Abbās ’Imād Tāriq bin ’Abdul’Azeez al-Mukhtār and Abū Usāmah Yāseen bin Muhammad Āl Nazāl in their 375 page book entitled al-Ibānah ’an Khiyānat is-Siyānah [li Ahmad Bāzmūl] li ’Adl wa Amānah [Clarification About the Deception of Protection (by Ahmad Bāzmūl) in Justice and Trust].

An example of bias in the book is in regards to the issue of Bāzmūl’s claim that Shaykh Ali Hasan views that there has to be ijma’ for a Jarh to be accepted, when in fact Shaykh Ali Hasan merely emphasises what was stated by Imām adh-Dhahabī before, that there has to be an ijmā’ to impose a Jarh on others and obligate them to adhere to it. The issue was discussed in detail in the book mentioned above by Abu’l-’Abbās ’Imād Tāriq and Yāseen Āl Nazāl.

About Salafibayaan

Check Also

hand-writing-on-paper-with-pen

A fifth Letter to Khalid bin Dhawhi al-Dhafiri by Shaykh Saalim at-Taweel

Click here to Download file Approximately two years ago, I had offered a reward of …